CARDINAL JOE AND ARCHBISHOP RAY
|
|
I spent a night in Seattle, at the home of
Loren and June Arnett. Loren was then the Executive Director of the
Washington Association of Churches. As I remember it, Loren invited me
to a breakfast of Bishops of the various denominations. We guessed
that I was probably at least a Bishop in the Moment Ministries
hierarchy, so I could attend. |
I believe we met at a Lutheran Church that
morning. Loren fulfilled the servant role of setting up the breakfast
since he was no doubt the instigator of this fellowship. I didn’t know
what to expect, but as these people began to arrive it was obvious that
they were pretty ordinary people. No red hats or flowing robes or
anything like that. They called each other by first names. You had to
know them to know which denomination or branch of the religious tree
they were from. |
I’m not great at names, and didn’t know any
of the people personally except for Bob Brock, who was the “bishop” of
my denomination (although his title was “Regional Minister.”) One
fellow extended his hand, “Hi, I’m Ray.” I said, “Hi, I’m Art.” |
As we were heading wherever we went after the
breakfast, Loren told me who some of the people were. Ray was actually
Archbishop Ray Hunthausen, the spiritual leader of Western Washington’s
Catholics. He was sometimes controversial, said Loren. “A really neat
guy.” |
Later, as I read news of various clergy
activities in Washington, I noticed that my friend Ray was often right
in the midst of them. In fact, he was so much in the midst of them that
then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (who recently changed his name to Pope
Benedict XVI) came down on Ray for associating with the “wrong” people
and holding some “wrong ideas.” |
According to a report from 1985, then-Cardinal Joe
“disciplined Hunthausen for a variety of doctrinal and pastoral
concerns, including the archdiocese’s ministries to gays and lesbians,
such as hosting of weekly services at St. Joseph’s for Dignity Seattle,
the state chapter of a national organization of gay Catholics.”
|
You probably didn’t think Archbishops did
anything except say Mass and go around visiting parishes. But Ray was
active enough that he got the attention of Rome.
“In one of the Vatican’s most widely publicized reports, Ratzinger
warned him against politicizing the issue of women in the church, the
use of married ex-priests, marrying divorced people and giving them
communion rights, giving communion in ecumenical settings, and granting
general absolution of sins to large groups.” (Quotes from Associated
Press in the Corvallis Gazette-Times, 4/9/05)
|
In fact, for a period of time, Archbishop Ray
was relieved of some of his authority in the church. Another bishop was
sent to keep him straight. There was such an uproar from American
bishops, priests, nuns and other Catholics, that he got his authority
back. |
Then, as today, there are a lot of people who
praise the heavy hand that exercises authority. The Church has its
rules and practices. The whole Catholic system is built on people
promising to live by rules centuries old, and to obey doctrines and
dogmas over 1500 years old. |
What happens, though, when someone like Jesus
appears and doesn’t bow down to the Temple system? What happens when he
strays from strict rules to associate with the wrong people? The
cardinals of his time rebuked him for his association with
tax-collectors and prostitutes and wine-drinkers and sinners. How could
he dare heal and forgive and disobey centuries old Sabbath laws? |
The more I think of it, the more I ask how a
Christian of any sort, archbishop or not, could walk on the other side
of the people my friend Ray reached out to. Jesus seemed to think that
compassion trumped doctrine any day. |
I guess you could say that you can’t run a
world-wide church with loose cannons like Hunthausen. But what’s the
point of having a church if you don’t care about those for whom Jesus
cared? |
There are those who side with Ratzinger and
like to hold the line. And there are those who side with Hunthausen who
would have favored a more broadminded pope. Fundamentalists, Mormons
and others whose beliefs are rooted in traditions from other times
favor Joe’s position more than Ray’s. |
I’ve known some priests fairly well. I know
what they think and believe and practice, although their public front
is quite traditional. The ones I happen to know are more like Ray than
like Joe. |
If Loren ever has a chance to arrange a
meeting that includes both Ray and Joe, I’d love to be invited. I’d
love to see Pope Benedict say to Archbishop Ray, “Hi, I’m Joe.”
— Art Morgan, May 2005
|